Neighborhood Guide

Sheepshead Bay

Sheepshead Bay is a bay separating the mainland of Brooklyn, New York City, from the eastern portion of Coney Island, the latter originally a barrier island but now effectively an extension of the mainland with peninsulas both east (the neighborhood of Manhattan Beach) and west (the neighborhoods of Coney Island and Sea Gate). The mouth of the bay is about 1.0 mile (1.6 km) southwest of Marine Park, Brooklyn.

Sheepshead Bay Listings

3 BR at 1733 EAST 14TH STREET, #D

RLS

1733 EAST 14TH STREET, #D
Condo • Sheepshead Bay
$750,000
3 BR | 2 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Keller Williams NYC
1 BR at 2241 PLUMB 1ST STREET, #1N

RLS

2241 PLUMB 1ST STREET, #1N
Coop • Sheepshead Bay
$190,000
1 BR | 1 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Keller Williams Realty Empire
1 BR at 2654 EAST 18TH STREET, #3D

RLS

2654 EAST 18TH STREET, #3D
Condo • Sheepshead Bay
$495,000
1 BR | 1 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Compass
1 BR at 1717 EAST 18TH STREET, #6M

RLS

1717 EAST 18TH STREET, #6M
Coop • Sheepshead Bay
$375,000
1 BR | 1 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Griffith Real Estate LLC
5 BR at 2783 BATCHELDER STREET

RLS

2783 BATCHELDER STREET
Townhouse • Sheepshead Bay
$1,298,000
2 FM | 5 BR | 2 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Douglas Elliman Real Estate
1 BR at 7 LAKE AVENUE

RLS

7 LAKE AVENUE
Townhouse • Sheepshead Bay
$350,000
1 FM | 1 BR | 1 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Revived Residential
2 BR at 1501 VOORHIES AVENUE, #24B

RLS

1501 VOORHIES AVENUE, #24B
Condo • Sheepshead Bay
$995,000
2 BR | 2 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Serhant LLC
1 BR at 2654 EAST 18TH STREET, #5D

RLS

2654 EAST 18TH STREET, #5D
Condo • Sheepshead Bay
$530,000
1 BR | 1 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Compass
1 BR at 2600 EAST 21ST STREET, #4C

RLS

2600 EAST 21ST STREET, #4C
Coop • Sheepshead Bay
$249,000
1 BR | 1 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Compass
1 BR at 2654 EAST 18TH STREET, #2D

RLS

2654 EAST 18TH STREET, #2D
Condo • Sheepshead Bay
$460,000
1 BR | 1 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Compass
1 BR at 3203 NOSTRAND AVENUE, #6J

RLS

3203 NOSTRAND AVENUE, #6J
Coop • Sheepshead Bay
$263,000
1 BR | 1 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Douglas Elliman Real Estate
2 BR at 2384 OCEAN AVENUE, #3A/PS2

RLS

2384 OCEAN AVENUE, #3A/PS2
Condo • Sheepshead Bay
$668,000
2 BR | 2 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Nest Seekers LLC

Current Sales (32)

Size	Starting from	Listings Count	Avg. $/Ft²	DOM
Studio	$229.0K	1	-	68
1 BR	$190.0K	11	$531	216
2 BR	$230.0K	16	$667	182
3 BR	$350.0K	4	$636	158

$458

Avg. Price/SqFt.

Prices Trend (2012-2024)

All Sizes

Studio

1 BR

2 BR

3 BR